In a Dumpling Baked

Gargoyle, Cathedral, Strasbourg, Religious Monuments

In dappled sunlight
The gargoyle gagged on spinach
In a dumpling baked
A new leaf of which was caught
On the tip of the beast’s tongue

The paint chip words and phrases you have to choose from are ivory, tip of the tongue, dappled sunlight, spinach, new leaf, gargoyle, and dumpling.